Wikipedia:Peer review/Charles Keeping/archive1
I'd like some input to put Keeping's work into context. I don't know enough about artists and illustrators to be able to identify the major influences on his work, or what else was going on in illustration and Keeping's place in it. I also think more opinions would enrich the article. --User:Nicknack009
- Personally, I think your article is brilliant. In fact, I read almost to the bottom and I though to myself "wow. This is the first PR I've read that doesn't actually need any work!". However, then I noticed this: "Through the Window in particular is an astonishingly beautiful piece of work." That seems to be a POV... unless you can clarify who said this I think you need to fix it. I realise you are a fan, but be careful with too much praise, cause you can't do that here :) Also, this article needs references. See Wikipedia:Cite sources for more info on formatting, etc. However, all that said: this is such a brilliant job I reckon it should go onto WP:FAC! In fact, I think there's a good chance Raul might pick it for the front page... - Ta bu shi da yu 14:51, 30 Dec 2004 (UTC)